Written by Editorial Team on February 3, 2020

6 Best WordPress Membership Plugins For 2020

Best WordPress Membership Plugin
Best WordPress membership plugin

Which is the best WordPress membership plugin? If you want to transform your WordPress site into a fully functional membership site, you need a WordPress membership plugin. With a WordPress membership site plugin, you can create a premium content library and make it accessible only to your registered members. These registered members can either be free members or paid members (based on your settings).

Choosing the right and best WordPress membership plugin is crucial for your business because a better platform means more opportunity for growth. In this article, we will compare 6 best WordPress membership plugins to easily create paid membership websites.

We decided to publish this "best membership plugins for WordPress" guide because we were searching for the best membership plugins for our new membership platform.

We are using WishList Member plugin and we could be a little bias here!

Editorial Team @ WP Maven

WishList Member

WishList Member Best Membership Plugin WordPress
WishList Member is one of the oldest and best WordPress membership plugins

Top of the chart of the best membership plugin for WordPress is WishList Member. If you had been a WordPress user over a decade ago, WishList Member or WLM, in short, is a household name in the WordPress community. They were dominating the WordPress membership plugin market until a period where they did lesser upgrade compared to other plugins ... and ultimately dropping out from the rat race.

What is WishList Member plugin?

WishList Member is a plugin that transforms any WordPress site into a full-fledged membership site with protected online content.

There are many WordPress membership plugins and we really had a hard time trying to decide. But ended up, we decided to go with the WishList Member plugin. Here's why:

  • Create a membership site with an unlimited number of levels, each with its own unique access options
  • Protect members-only online content and ensure proper access in a few simple clicks
  • Integrate your membership plans with payment providers, email providers, and more
  • est for: Entrepreneurs, web developers, and agencies that want to create a membership site for premium content

As our online course covers both free and paid membership levels, creating multiple membership levels can be a tough job to do. Thankfully, the WishList Member plugin allows us to do that easily.

Here's how.

How WishList Member Plugin Works
Create multiple levels of membership with WishList Member plugin

The plugin makes it easy for you to protect content published on your WordPress site by specifying which membership levels have access to everything from pages, posts, comments, files, folders, and custom post types.

How to create restrict content for members using WishList Member plugin
Restrict access to content by specifying which membership levels have access to which content and files.

With WishList Member, you can take control of the user experience by managing things like levels of password security and email opt-ins.

Control The User Experience With WishList Member Plugin
Quickly and easily update user information and manage individual access for each member

Apart from that, we decided to use WishList Member plugin because it integrates with a ton load of third-party tools. And, integrating the plugin with these tools are extremely easy.

Integration With Third Party Marketing Tools
WishList Member plugin integrates with dozens of marketing tools

Last but not least, the WishList Member plugin allows us to create a simple but highly customized WordPress login page for our membership site.

Create Custom Login Page for Membership Sites
Easily create a custom login page for your membership site

Summary: WishList Member plugin is one of the best membership plugins for WordPress. If you have been searching for the right membership plugin, we recommend you to try WishList Member today (with pricings start from $147 for a single WordPress site.


MemberMouse Best Membership Plugin WordPress
MemberMouse is a popular membership plugin for WordPress

The second best membership plugin for WordPress is MemberMouse. We like MemberMouse but the monthly commitment is something we try to shave off (as much as possible).

What we love about MemberMouse is the fact that it is super intuitive, easy to use and comes with excellent WordPress maintenance history (constant upgrades).

What are the advantages/features of MemberMouse?

  • Register new members and accept orders with highly configurable and easy to use checkout pages
  • Easily password-protect pages to deliver premium content, PDFs, videos, software and more
  • Let customers update their profile, billing details, email, password, cancel subscriptions, and more
  • Get a handle on critical metrics including sales, lifetime value by source, and retention

Finally, MemberMouse comes with some of the craziest pricing for membership plugins (because it comes with explosive features). Instead of the yearly pricing, MemberMouse comes with monthly fees and based on the number of members you have.

Here's the pricing plans for MemberMouse.


Limited features and best for new membership sites


Recommended for most membership sites


Priority support and large membership sites

S2 Member

S2 Member Plugin Best WordPress Membership Plugin
S2 Member is a free membership plugin for WordPress

S2 Member is another popular membership plugin for WordPress. It is easy to use and with the price tag of "free", this is definitely one of the most popular membership plugins for WordPress users.

What are the advantages of using S2 Member?

  • Custom login welcome page
  • Membership options
  • Content protections
  • PayPal integration
  • Absolutely free to use

In our rating for the best membership plugins for WordPress, S2 Member scores rather well, but we dislike it as it is rather heavy and having a less intuitive user-interface. There is also paid S2 Member plans that start at $89 for a lifetime license.

Paid Memberships Pro

If you are looking for the best membership plugin for WordPress, you need to consider Paid Memberships Pro. What makes Paid Memberships Pro plugin a good membership solution for your WordPress site? Watch this video to learn more.

How good is Paid Memberships Pro?

Some of the best advantages using Paid Memberships Pro plugin are:

  • Unlimited levels
  • Recurring payments
  • Unique registration & profile fields
  • Protected member content
  • Robust member management

Want another option to choose this WordPress membership plugin? It comes with a free plan too!


- Plugin Download
- Documentation & Install Video
- 14 Free Add Ons


- Support and Updates for 1 to 5 Sites
- Unlimited Support Tickets
- 65 Plus Add Ons (a $3,200 value)
- 19 Free Add Ons
- 1-Click Add On Installs/Updates


- Support and Updates for Unlimited Sites
- Unlimited Support Tickets
- 65 Plus Add Ons (a $3,200 value)
- 19 Free Add Ons
- 1-Click Add On Installs/Updates

Restrict Content Pro

Restrict Content Pro Best WordPress Membership Plugin
Restrict Content Pro is one of the best paid membership plugins

Do you want to lock away your exclusive content and give access to valued members? Restrict Content Pro is often considered one of the best WordPress membership plugins that offers robust features in creating a membership site.

We find it easy to use Restrict Content Pro plugin and it is absolutely beginner-friendly. Here are some additional features about RCP:

  • Create an unlimited number of discount codes and offer percentage or flat rate based discounts
  • Accept credit cards with Stripe, Braintree, 2Checkout, or PayPal Website Payments Pro. Restrict Content Pro also supports PayPal Standard and Express, as well as multiple payment options at the same time
  • Elegant and easy-to-use reports to show you exactly how well your membership site is performing. Easily see the current month’s performance, or any other time period
  • Generate a CSV of all active members of any particular subscription level, or a CSV of every member in the system. You can also generate a CSV of every payment that has been made
  • Create an unlimited number of subscription packages. You can easily create free, trial, and premium subscriptions
  • Easily view all active, pending, expired, cancelled, and free users
  • Restrict Content Pro makes it extremely easy to deliver premium content to your subscribers
  • Send welcome emails to new members, email payment receipts, and remind members before their account expires automatically

So, how much does Restrict Content Pro plugin costs?


- 12 official free add-ons
-Plugin updates
- Email support
- 1 site
- All core features included
- Yearly subscription


- 12 official free add-ons
-Plugin updates
- Email support
- 5 sites
- All core features included
- Yearly subscription


- 17 pro add-ons (a massive $1020 value!)
- PLUS all future pro add-ons
- 12 official free add-ons
- Plugin updates
- Email support
- Unlimited sites
- All core features included
- Yearly subscription


- 17 pro add-ons (a massive $1020 value!)
- PLUS all future pro add-ons
- 12 official free add-ons
- Lifetime plugin updates
- Lifetime email support
- Unlimited sites
- All core features included
- Lifetime subscription (pay only once)


MemberPress Best WordPress Membership Plugin
MemberPress is one of the top best WordPress membership plugin

Last but not least, MemberPress made it to the list of the best WordPress membership plugin. But, what is MemberPress?

MemberPress is an easy to use WordPress Membership Plugin. It will help you to instantly start charging your users for access to your content. MemberPress will help you confidently create, manage and track membership subscriptions and sell digital download products.


MemberPress calls itself as the all-in-one membership plugin for WordPress.Here are some of the advantages using MemberPress:

  • Easy to use (beginner friendly)
  • Powerful access rules
  • Premium membership site creation (look and feel)
  • Coupons and voucher codes
  • Work with any WordPress theme
  • Content drip feature
  • Affiliate program
  • Clear and advanced reporting

So, how much does MemberPress costs?


- Use on 1 Site
- Unlimited Members & Content
- Works with PayPal & Stripe
- 1 Year of Support and Updates 
- More than 10 Add-Ons & Integrations


- All basic features
- Use on up to 2 Sites
- Works with
- Sell Corporate Accounts 
- 10 Additional Add-Ons & Integrations


- All basic and plus features
- Use on up to 5 Sites
- Includes Affiliate Royale
- Exclusive Pro Add-Ons*

Want to know more about MemberPress plugin? Check out their demo right here.

Which is the best WordPress membership plugin?

This is a tough call (really). It is important to understand that no two membership plugins are the same and most of them have their own advantages. At WP Maven, our focus (just like some of you guys) is to create a membership site fast and efficient.

In order to accomplish such, we need to have a good and easy to use WordPress membership site plugin—and we choose WishList Member for that matter.

What is your favorite and best WordPress membership plugin? Leave a comment below and let's discuss further.

Article written by Editorial Team

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Posts